New World Exploration
Contact
  • Explorers' Tales Blog
  • Bibliography
  • Contact

How the Discovery of Brazil Led to Naming America,  Part 1

4/1/2014

6 Comments

 
PictureVespucci landing in America, c. 1580 by van der Straet, Wikimedia Commons
Roger M.McCoy
As a school boy I learned that America was named for Amerigo Vespucci, and that fact was pretty much the end of the story. On further examination I later found  there is quite a story behind the name, with a surprising element of chicanery and chutzpah. It begins with the discovery of Brazil.

Portuguese and Spanish sailors quickly learned that the easiest route around the south tip of Africa’s Cape of Good Hope involved sailing far to the west in the northeasterly trade winds. After crossing the doldrums near the equator, they used the southeasterly trade winds until they picked up the westerlies, beyond 20˚ south latitude, then sailed eastward with a following wind to India. The westward arc was a longer distance than sailing directly along the coast of west Africa, but provided much easier and faster sailing. Also, taking such a route assured that someone would eventually discover Brazil.

It was while making such a maneuver in 1500 that the Spanish navigator, Martin Pinzón, a seasoned explorer who had commanded the Pinta on Columbus’s first voyage, became the first European to see the coast of Brazil. He landed near the eastern tip of Brazil, then sailed north, encountering sea water fresh enough to drink many miles from land. This phenomenon induced him to turn and sail into one of the mouths of the Amazon River. While there he cut and loaded a cargo of logwood (used to make dyes), captured some twenty or more natives, and returned to Spain. Upon reporting his find, the authorities determined from his logbook that the land discovered, was east of the line set by the Treaty of Tordesillas and therefore rightly belonged to Portugal.

In the same year, Portugal sent Pedro Álvares Cabral to cement Portugal’s advantage in south Asia. In March of 1500 he left Portugal with a fleet of fourteen vessels, sailing the westward arc that utilized the trade winds. Cabral, like Pinzón,  happened to encounter the eastern tip of Brazil where he sighted and named Monte Pascoal (Easter Mountain). They sailed into a large bay, now named Baia Cabrália in honor of Cabral. Sensing a good thing, Cabral immediately sent one ship, commanded by Captain Nicolau Coehlo directly back to Portugal with a detailed letter to inform investors and King Manuel I of their discovery. Cabral then continued on to India. News of the discovery quickly spread around Europe, and that same year was recorded on Juan de Cosa’s Mappemonde. 

This first contact with Brazil provided no clue about its immense wealth of resources, and it was first considered only a place to stop for wood and water on the way to India. Historian Greenlee said “Few voyages have been of greater importance to posterity, and few have been less appreciated in their time.”

Manuel I of Portugal sent a ship to Brazil in 1501 commanded by Gonçalo Coelho. Traveling with Coelho was a Florentine named Amerigo Vespucci, who was invited by the king to accompany this voyage and write about it. To understand how Vespucci came by such an invitation we must digress and learn a bit about the man. 

Amerigo Vespucci, born in 1454, has become one of the most controversial  characters in the history of discovery. Assessments of Vespucci range from a charlatan who, at one extreme, never even saw the New World, to a great navigator and discoverer who rightly deserves to have two continents and a nation named for him. He was born to an upperclass family with an ambassador, a bishop, and bankers in the family, and all connected with the powerful Medici family of Florence. In short, Amerigo was very well connected. Amerigo became an employee of the commercial enterprises of Lorenzo de Medici, and at about 40 years of age was sent to Seville as the head of a Medici affiliate. In this position Vespucci was involved with outfitting the Columbus fleet for its third voyage in 1498. He became well acquainted with Columbus, who praised him as a most excellent and honest ship chandler. But Amerigo aspired to the fame of an explorer and left the mundane world of business and finance. His first actual voyage occurred in 1499, on which he traveled to the West Indies under the command of Alonso de Ojeda. Perhaps Amerigo even helped finance that 1499 voyage. On this voyage Vespucci gained some practical experience in navigation.

Apparently something happened between him and Ojeda, and Vespucci abandoned the expedition in Hispaniola and returned to Seville on another ship ahead of Ojeda. Then Vespucci wrote a full account of the 1499 voyage as though it had been his own expedition with no mention of Ojeda, and through his writing convinced the king and financiers that he was an experienced navigator. This may be a good example of a person with some knowledge but little practical experience, who has the gift of convincing people that he is far more capable than his experience would suggest. Vespucci also wrote an elaborate descriptive account of a bogus voyage that supposedly sailed two years earlier, in 1497, under his command. 

Soon Vespucci came to the attention of Manuel I who had just appointed Gonçalo Coelho to go assess Portugal’s new possession in 1501. Thus Vespucci received a royal invitation to go along on this voyage and write about it. Because Amerigo had some earlier experience as a navigator under Ojeda, he took on the job of navigation officer, and he wrote of the voyage with great flourish and self-serving skills. His report was important because it was the first chance for Portugal to see just what they had acquired under the new Treaty of Tordesillas that divided the undiscovered world between Spain and Portugal.

Vespucci published his account in the form of long letters, called Lettera in 1504, and a second tract, Mundus Novus. Both received great distribution and circulation in Spain, Portugal, and other parts of Europe. These letters brought great recognition to Amerigo. Unfortunately there was no benefit or fame for the captain of the expedition, Coelho, because Vespucci never mentions him in either publication. Vespucci claimed to be on his third voyage but, of course, it was really only his second. Again the thirst for information about the New World made Vespucci a well-known name and gave him great publicity. 

Many historians now challenge parts of Amerigo’s writing as false and often exaggerated, especially his claim that the voyage would have been lost without his knowledge of navigation, “Though a man without practical experience, yet through the teaching of the marine chart for navigation, I was more skilled than all the shipmasters of the world.” This guy had chutzpah. To be fair, Vespucci’s narratives were very descriptive and thorough in relating the sights and people along the coastal area of Brazil. Furthermore, they were widely read and popular among the educated class. His deceptions were about where he went and when.      

(To be continued soon in part 2)


6 Comments
Michael Yeager
4/2/2014 11:28:41 pm

Some things in the political arena never change. No wonder the truth isn't always taught in history class.

Reply
Roger McCoy
4/4/2014 08:01:49 am

Also, there have always the self-promoting charlatans who somehow get away with it.

Reply
led lighting link
11/4/2015 02:52:04 am



Its awesome experience to view your blog. I appreciate your work,

Reply
Roger McCoy
11/4/2015 03:36:06 pm

Thanks for letting me know. It is a great pleasure to hear from someone who enjoyed the blogs.

Reply
Vilson Martin
5/29/2022 06:00:26 am

That is the reason the Map of AMERICA should be in Brazil and not in the United States. The America's history was snatched by these English speaking countries

Reply
Roger
5/31/2022 12:27:38 pm

Thanks for your comment. I agree with the idea that artifacts should remain in their country of origin. I also recognize that it is a fairly recent concept. In the 16th through the early 20th century Europeans felt free to take what they wanted from a different culture. Spain, Portugal, and England hauled boatloads of gold and other valuables back to their home countries. In the U.S. Americans of European descent held the same attitude toward native people. Change is very slow, but theft from other cultures is gradually becoming unacceptable, and return of artifacts or some form of compensation is sometimes made. Unfortunately there is some resistance to compensating for deeds of the past.

Reply



Leave a Reply.


    "Explorers' Tales"
    A blog article is only a starting point in learning about explorers. References with each article provide further reading. Explorer's original journals are especially interesting and are quoted in the blog when possible.   

    Archives

    May 2020
    June 2018
    May 2018
    March 2018
    May 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014

    Topics
    Life at Sea Part 2 5/6/2020
    Before Columbus 6/29/2018
    Explorer Priests 5/29/2018
    Cabeza de Vaca 3/28/2018
    Vikings  5/2/2017
    Longitude  3/28/2017
    The Compass 2/22/2017
    Captain Cook 1/31/2017
    Humboldt 12/28/2016
    ​Fremont  8/26/2016
    Columbus  7/25/2016
    Life at sea  6/26/2016
    Navigation   5/28/2016
    Lewis & Clark Part 3  4/21/2016
    Lewis & Clark Part 2  4/2/2016
    ​Lewis & Clark Part 1 3/20/2016
    Stefansson 2/21/2016
    ​Sverdrup 1/9/2016
    ​Smallpox 12/13/2015

    John Rae 10/25/2015
    Franklin, Part 3  10/1/2015
    Franklin, Part 2  9/18/2015
    Sir John Franklin 9/2/2015
    Columbian Exchange 8/1/2015
    Myths: Cities of Gold  7/6/2015
    Esteban the slave 6/13/2015
    Cortes in Mexico 5/3/2015
    Earliest Accounts 4/14/2015

    Wintering in Arctic 3/26/2015
    Company Men 3/15/2015
    Company Explorers 2/19/2015
    Science Illustrators 2/3/2015
    Western Artists 1/22/2015
    Jacques Cartier  12/6/2014
    Explorer's Health 11/18/2014
    John Cabot 11/1/14
    Ponce de Leon !0/14/2014
    Food 10/1/2014
    Hearne 9/15/2014
    Frobisher 9/1/2014
    Frobisher 8/18/2014
    Explorers as artists 8/1/2014
    Davis 7/15/2014
    Drake 6/11/14
    Balboa 5/20/14
    Verrazzano 5/1/14
    Vespucci Part 2 4/13/14
    Vespucci Part 1 4/1/14
    Scurvy  3/15/14
    Henry Hudson Part 3, 3/3/14
    Henry Hudson Part 2, 2/24/14
    Henry Hudson Part 1, 2/6/14
    Early Arctic Science 1/24/14

    All

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.